Consciousness

Consciousness is a pretty complicated topic, but not because consciousness is particularly difficult, but because there are too many midwits who can’t decide what it is. So that is why I am here.

Among millennials, consciousness is just a synonym for ‘soul’, though it is fundamentally different from it. And some people nowadays define consciousness by what it isn’t. Namely, that consciousness is whatever is in the brain that we don’t currently understand.

What is it?

I subscribe to Julian Jaynes’ definition of consciousness. I do so because his is the most reasonable definition, that I have seen at least. He explains it in his book The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind, which I haven’t finished reading. Don’t worry, I’ve read all of the stuff actually relevant to this article. Jaynes tends to explain stuff in a bit of a strange way, so I’ll sum it up from how I understood it.

Understanding consciousness is done best by understanding what its actual function is, something that I have not seen many people think about.

The purpose of consciousness is not to make us self-aware, that’s more of a means to an end for its actual function.

Consciousness is a decision-making and directing engine. Its purpose is to help you (assuming you, the reader, are conscious) make decisions in novel situations and to provide direction if you’re unsure of what to do. A secondary function is to help you explain your own actions. It does this because consciousness is essentially a story you tell yourself about yourself, using your memories as a means of explaining yourself to yourself.

To make this clearer, think about the various questions you have no doubt asked yourself several times in your life.

  • “What should I do now?”
  • “How do I do this?”

Your consciousness does these to give you a direction. Basically, it’s so that if you’re stuck on a deserted island or being mugged by elephants or replacing a smoke alarm you’ll be able to figure out what to do.

Consciousness isn’t your complete self, which is evidenced by the fact you can often surprise yourself by the things you do. “Why did I just do that?” and so on. At which point you’ll explain to yourself (and sometimes to other people) why you did something, as if you consciously chose to do it, which you didn’t, of course. But then you’ll think you did, because deceiving yourself is very easy.

And that also provides a perfect explanation for why your brain/emotions can sometimes completely overpower your conscious reasoning, because the conscious reasoning is (architecturally) inherently subservient to those things.

This is also why ‘identity’ seems to exist at all too, because identity helps explain who you are. And who you are makes it easier to figure out what you’re supposed to do. If you’re a baker, you’ll think that it’s natural to figure out how to bake something. On the aforementioned deserted island, you may choose to build a bakery, because being a baker is who you are, right? If you’ve asked yourself the question “who am I really?” or you went out to ‘discover’ yourself, you were working on this part of consciousness. I mean, who else would you be telling these things? Only you can hear your own thoughts.

This self-narrativizing aspect of consciousness is also why you will often reframe your entire life around a completely new interest you developed recently, and gather evidence to back that this is who you have always been. Yes, you picking up the guitar in college is proof that you’ve always had a musical heart. Just like you abandoning the guitar is proof that it was just a passing fad.

You may protest that this seems awfully simple for consciousness, because it is. This is a limited consciousness model. One of the side-effects of the story that consciousness generates from you is the belief that everything is handled by consciousness.

You are not conscious 24/7. But consciousness feels continuous to people experiencing it. Isn’t that a bit strange? Well, not really no, because that’s kinda the point. Consciousness is a continuous narrative that you experience, so interruptions are simply not included. It’s like how you rarely see any of the times characters drive somewhere in movies…because they aren’t important for the story.

Along similar lines, you may have trouble remembering things that contradict the current narrative of your life. Which is also a nofix kind of bug of consciousness.

That’s a bit of a side-note though, the overall point is that consciousness isn’t responsible for managing everything about you. This is a fairly common-sense position to reach once I point out that you are not thinking about your left elbow at this time. Or about how you aren’t manually breathing. Naturally, now that I pointed it out, you are aware of these things, but you weren’t until I did.

Similarly, if I were to stab you without you knowing, then you would immediately become aware of it, because your brain would be telling your consciousness “ow”.

Another aspect of consciousness is that it makes it possible to analyze your own thoughts, and consequently gives you the tools to analyze other peoples’ behavior. In other words, it lets you build mental models of other people.

I’ll note though that the unconscious part of you seems to do this as well, so it’s not unique to consciousness, but consciousness seems necessary for things like lying and deception (at least the way Jaynes put it). More may be written by me on this in the future.

If you want to be really cynical, then you can think of consciousness as a hallucination that you are experiencing almost all the time.

A related question is where consciousness is in the brain. Jaynes provides an answer, which is why I know basically exactly where it is. Consciousness is probably located within the language centers of the left brain. The Bicameral Mind situation explains why this is. The gist of it is that, originally, this wasn’t really the case.

The way I understand the way consciousness interacts with the rest of the brain is that the rest of the brain ‘interprets’ what consciousness wants from it, and the brain in turn supplies signals that consciousness turns into awareness. Or it just becomes aware of them. But if this is how it works, then the brain is actually sometimes pretty piss-poor at this, because you usually have a lot more knowledge crammed in there than you are consciously aware of and the worst part is that you normally can’t even access it very well.

Some people, like CGP Grey may think that this creates some grand philosophical conundrum because if consciousness is only a small part of the brain (which it is), then does that mean that the rest of the brain is conscious? I’m using CGP Grey as an example because he suggested that the left brain and the right brain are separate consciousnesses which shows how he’s just a bit dumb, to put it lightly. Or, instead of arguing along those lines, you may find yourself crushed by finding that consciousness isn’t as grand or mysterious or whatever as you imagined it would be.

Regarding the first of these: no, you are not separate from the rest of the brain. To use an analogy, consciousness is more like a steering wheel. The steering wheel isn’t the car, but it’s a part of the car that helps determine the direction its heading in. If you removed it, the car would be lesser, though the car would largely continue to function.

If you’re a computer guy, you can think of the brain as being the hardware. The subconscious being the operating system, and consciousness being the graphical shell. The shell isn’t the operating system, nor is it the hardware, but it helps you work with both of those.

It being a steering wheel or shell doesn’t make it any less important.

Some other notes

I suddenly remembered this, but Jaynes seems to assume in his book that a vivid visual imagination plus an audible internal narration is necessary for consciousness. At the time, he probably wouldn’t have been fully aware of things like aphantasia (or how common it is), so this is understandable.

I’m writing this just to address that, because while I think he wrote the definition of consciousness with these things in mind, these things are not actually necessary for consciousness to exist. Though language is a prerequisite for consciousness, and so might be writing.

Non-verbal consciousness (or “vibes-based” if you prefer) is a thing. Though that might raise the question of “what is being non-conscious like then” and I would simply direct you towards the activity of spacing out.