Essarr LoreBook

Trying to go against the current

User Tools

Site Tools


lb:wc:retcons

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision
Previous revision
lb:wc:retcons [2026-02-13 17:39:03] – [Warcraft Retcons] ninjasrlb:wc:retcons [2026-10-28 14:52:59] (current) – [Elune] ninjasr
Line 41: Line 41:
 ==== Draenei ==== ==== Draenei ====
  
-The Draenei originally had a completely different backstory and were, get this, //native to Draenor//. After the orcs appeared, they started wiping them out.\\  By //The Frozen Throne// there are fewer of them, but they're still capable of fighting back. Their leader was Akama and, in the Blood Elf campaign, he's who you ally yourself with.\\  This was retconned...like...okay, this is one of the more perplexing retcons because there are two possibilities:+The [[lb:wc:Draenei]] originally had a completely different backstory and were, get this, //native to [[lb:wc:Draenor]]//. After the orcs appeared, they started wiping them out.\\  By //The Frozen Throne// there are fewer of them, but they're still capable of fighting back. Their leader was [[lb:wc:Akama]] and, in the [[lb:wc:blood elves|Blood Elf]] campaign, he's who you ally yourself with.\\  This was retconned...like...okay, this is one of the more perplexing retcons because there are two possibilities:
  
   * The writers forgot about Warcraft 3.   * The writers forgot about Warcraft 3.
Line 50: Line 50:
 ==== Illidan's death ==== ==== Illidan's death ====
  
-At the end of //The Frozen Throne//, Illidan and Arthas fight and, at the end of that fight, he gets slashed and is left to bleed out in the snow. This cinematic naturally heavily implies that Illidan //died//.\\  However, Illidan later re-appears in WoW as if little has happened and he continues being a thorn in the side of everyone.\\  What I find interesting about this retcon is that I vaguely remember it being discussed at some point, but has since been entirely forgotten about.\\  Also, the Warcraft Wiki amusingly claims that it was the original //intent// to show Illidan dying, but this didn't make it in due to time constraints. Never have I seen such obvious ‘cope’ in my life.\\  Also also, when I was about 13 years old, I was playing a custom campaign which continued the Blood Elf story after //The Frozen Throne//. In the first mission, I witnessed Illidan's rescue and, consequently, saw his recovery. At the time, I assumed it was bad fanfiction...now I know that, no, it was an adaptation of the post-WC3 story.+At the end of //The Frozen Throne//, [[lb:wc:Illidan]] and [[lb:wc:Arthas]] fight and, at the end of that fight, he gets slashed and is left to bleed out in the snow. This cinematic naturally heavily implies that Illidan //died//.\\  However, Illidan later re-appears in WoW as if little has happened and he continues being a thorn in the side of everyone.\\  What I find interesting about this retcon is that I vaguely remember it being discussed at some point, but has since been entirely forgotten about.\\  Also, the Warcraft Wiki amusingly claims that it was the original //intent// to show Illidan dying, but this didn't make it in due to time constraints. Never have I seen such obvious ‘cope’ in my life.\\  Also also, when I was about 13 years old, I was playing a custom campaign which continued the Blood Elf story after //The Frozen Throne//. In the first mission, I witnessed Illidan's rescue and, consequently, saw his recovery. At the time, I assumed it was bad fanfiction...now I know that, no, it was an adaptation of the post-WC3 story.
  
 ===== World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich King ===== ===== World of Warcraft: Wrath of the Lich King =====
Line 56: Line 56:
 ==== ‘There must always be a Lich King’ ==== ==== ‘There must always be a Lich King’ ====
  
-This is definitely a retcon and a very stupid one.\\  Basically, at the end of the expansion, after you defeat the Lich King...Bolvar takes his place on the throne, donning the Helm of Domination and then...Bolvar is the new Lich King. The justification given for why this is done is...that there must always be a Lich King.\\  However, none of the previous story up to this point indicate that this needed to be the case.\\  I mean, let's think about this logically for a second: there was a point in Azeroth's history where a Lich King didn't exist...but even assuming if something fundamentally changed, this is a very unusual thing to assume.\\  Now, this is me fixing the story on behalf of Blizzard, but one way it could have been justified is if a Lich King were needed to control the Scourge because, otherwise, they'd go completely haywire...causing chaos and destruction. Though, again, I'm the one doing this...Blizzard never provides this kind of justification.\\  Another way this could have been justified is as a form of controlled extermination. While the Horde and Alliance were busy eliminating the Scourge, they could have had Bolvar control it to prevent it from fighting back. This is also something that Blizzard would not have done, because status quo...the undead just kinda have to exist here now despite being against the natural order.\\  As far as I know, //Chris Metzen// (yes, really) is the one responsible for this...and he did it just because they thought it would be cool. I don't think this should have ever been done, though.+This is definitely a retcon and a very stupid one.\\  Basically, at the end of the expansion, after you defeat the [[lb:wc:Lich King]]...[[lb:wc:Bolvar]] takes his place on the throne, donning the Helm of Domination and then...Bolvar is the new Lich King. The justification given for why this is done is...that there must always be a Lich King.\\  However, none of the previous story up to this point indicate that this needed to be the case.\\  I mean, let's think about this logically for a second: there was a point in [[lb:wc:Azeroth]]’s history where a Lich King didn't exist...but even assuming if something fundamentally changed, this is a very unusual thing to assume.\\  Now, this is me fixing the story on behalf of Blizzard, but one way it could have been justified is if a Lich King were needed to control the [[lb:wc:Scourge]] because, otherwise, they'd go completely haywire...causing chaos and destruction. Though, again, I'm the one doing this...Blizzard never provides this kind of justification.\\  Another way this could have been justified is as a form of controlled extermination. While the Horde and Alliance were busy eliminating the Scourge, they could have had Bolvar control it to prevent it from fighting back. This is also something that Blizzard would not have done, because status quo...the undead just kinda have to exist here now despite being against the natural order.\\  As far as I know, //[[lb:Chris Metzen]]// (yes, really) is the one responsible for this...and he did it just because they thought it would be cool. I don't think this should have ever been done, though.
  
 ===== World of Warcraft: Cataclysm ===== ===== World of Warcraft: Cataclysm =====
Line 62: Line 62:
 ==== Sea Witch ==== ==== Sea Witch ====
  
-The Warcraft 3 Demo's Orc campaign((:fn:>Which is the only campaign in the demo, so specifying it is kinda pointless...?))((:fn:>Also available in //The Frozen Throne// via the Custom Campaign menu as, basically, the game's second bonus campaign.)) has a ‘[[lb:wc:zar'jira|Sea Witch]]’ as the primary antagonist in the second half of the story.\\  In Warcraft 3, she's depicted with a Ghost model/portrait/voice. Cataclysm claims that she was a [[lb:wc:naga]] the whole time, technically making this a retcon.\\  Reforged takes this a step further and just turns her into a Naga Sea Witch, though I'd consider that a separate retcon.\\  Her being a Naga the whole time is the first positive retcon that I'm listing here and, so far, appears to be the only one.\\  This is a good retcon because it doesn't over-write information as much as it elaborates on a mystery...that mystery being ‘what the Fel was the Sea Witch?’\\  Even her vague warning about a coming dark tide now fits neatly in with the Naga stuff.\\  However, the Reforged one? I'd say that was probably a negative change all things considered. I think she should have remained a shadowy, mysterious ghostly figure...maybe only slightly hinting at the fact she's a Naga. Because of this change, the Horde knew about the Naga existing waaaaay before anybody else: they literally met one. Originally, they had no clue what she was or who she was...but now they pretty clearly know she was some strange fish/snake creature. I may also be over-thinking this point, but I really don't think this was a change for the better.\\  But otherwise? Yeah, positive. Good job Blizzard.+The Warcraft 3 Demo's Orc campaign((:fn:>Which is the only campaign in the demo, so specifying it is kinda pointless...?))((:fn:>Also available in //The Frozen Throne// via the Custom Campaign menu as, basically, the game's second bonus campaign.)) has a ‘[[lb:wc:zar'jira|Sea Witch]]’ as the primary antagonist in the second half of the story.\\  In Warcraft 3, she's depicted with a Ghost model/portrait/voice. Cataclysm claims that she was a [[lb:wc:naga]] the whole time, technically making this a retcon.\\  Reforged takes this a step further and just turns her into a Naga Sea Witch, though I'd consider that a separate retcon.\\  Her being a Naga the whole time is the first positive retcon that I'm listing here and, so far, appears to be the only one.\\  This is a good retcon because it doesn't over-write information as much as it elaborates on a mystery...that mystery being ‘what the [[lb:wc:Fel]] was the Sea Witch?’\\  Even her vague warning about a coming dark tide now fits neatly in with the Naga stuff.\\  However, the Reforged one? I'd say that was probably a negative change all things considered. I think she should have remained a shadowy, mysterious ghostly figure...maybe only slightly hinting at the fact she's a Naga. Because of this change, the Horde knew about the Naga existing waaaaay before anybody else: they literally met one. Originally, they had no clue what she was or who she was...but now they pretty clearly know she was some strange fish/snake creature. I may also be over-thinking this point, but I really don't think this was a change for the better.\\  But otherwise? Yeah, positive. Good job Blizzard.
  
 [[woww>Zar'jira]] [[woww>Sea Witch (Warcraft III)]] [[woww>Zar'jira]] [[woww>Sea Witch (Warcraft III)]]
Line 70: Line 70:
 ==== Tyrande's Hair Color ==== ==== Tyrande's Hair Color ====
  
-This is one of those ‘pointless retcons’.\\  In Warcraft 3 and //The Frozen Throne//, Tyrande has dark blue hair (navy). In WoW, this was changed to her having teal hair. In a now-deleted tweet, which is cited on the Warcraft wiki, it's stated that she dyes her hair teal. So we can assume that, sometime before WoW, she started dyeing her hair.\\  However, in Reforged, her hair color was changed to match her WoW appearance...so teal hair. This means that her dyeing her hair was retconned to start much earlier than previously believed.\\  I fully realize that this is a ‘who cares’ situation in the grand scheme of things...but //I// care because that Night Elf box art((:fn:>And that is confirmed to be Tyrande...somewhere.)) was one of little Ninja's first waifus. Further, I don't think I liked the ‘hair dyeing’ thing at all and — and I will die on this hill — she looks better with navy hair. Sorry not sorry.\\  But, like, guys...seriously? You saw the original game and yet you still screwed up?+This is one of those ‘pointless retcons’.\\  In Warcraft 3 and //The Frozen Throne//, [[lb:wc:Tyrande]] has dark blue hair (navy). In WoW, this was changed to her having teal hair. In a now-deleted tweet, which is cited on the Warcraft wiki, it's stated that she dyes her hair teal. So we can assume that, sometime before WoW, she started dyeing her hair.\\  However, in Reforged, her hair color was changed to match her WoW appearance...so teal hair. This means that her dyeing her hair was retconned to start much earlier than previously believed.\\  I fully realize that this is a ‘who cares’ situation in the grand scheme of things...but //I// care because that Night Elf box art((:fn:>And that is confirmed to be Tyrande...somewhere.)) was one of little Ninja's first waifus. Further, I don't think I liked the ‘hair dyeing’ thing at all and — and I will die on this hill — she looks better with navy hair. Sorry not sorry.\\  But, like, guys...seriously? You saw the original game and yet you still screwed up?
  
 [[woww>Tyrande Whisperwind#Notes_and_trivia]] [[woww>Tyrande Whisperwind#Notes_and_trivia]]
Line 78: Line 78:
 ==== Elune ==== ==== Elune ====
  
-Elune is the super mysterious goddess of the [[lb:wc:nelf|Night Elves]] and, to this day...is somehow still the most mysterious goddess in Warcraft.\\  The retcon I'm referring to is ‘Azeroth's only true god’ which is apparently said somewhere in Warcraft 3. This is also referenced in the Warcraft RPG. But, since then, it's likely been retconned to Hell and back.\\  My guess is that, originally, Elune was the Light. The Light allows people to heal others  and, well, the Moon Wells are the primary means of healing others for the Night Elf faction. Plus the Light's nature is kinda ambiguous as well (until it's retconned) so...\\  That's a guess though, but Elune as Azeroth's only god is definitely something that got retconned.+[[lb:wc:Elune]] is the super mysterious goddess of the [[lb:wc:nelf|Night Elves]] and, to this day...is somehow still the most mysterious goddess in Warcraft.\\  The retcon I'm referring to is ‘Azeroth's only true god’ which is apparently said somewhere in Warcraft 3. This is also referenced in the Warcraft RPG. But, since then, it's likely been retconned to Hell and back.\\  My guess is that, originally, Elune was the [[lb:wc:Light]]. The Light allows people to heal others  and, well, the Moon Wells are the primary means of healing others for the Night Elf faction. Plus the Light's nature is kinda ambiguous as well (until it's retconned) so...\\  That's a guess though, but Elune as Azeroth's only god is definitely something that got retconned.
  
 [[woww>Elune]] [[woww>Elune]]
lb/wc/retcons.1771004343.txt.gz · Last modified: 2026-02-13 17:39:03 by ninjasr

Donate Powered by PHP Valid HTML5 Valid CSS Driven by DokuWiki